PVT. OLIVER ROBINSON

by Jessica Hoehn, Local History & Genealogy Specialist

Many soldiers of the Revolution left their hometowns after the war for new areas to lay down roots. Some of these soldiers eventually found their way to Ohio, often bringing their families with them to settle in the (at the time) new state. This year, we’ll take a look at the soldiers who settled in Seneca County and learn more about them.

Sudbury, Massachusetts Revolutionary War memorial.

https://www.massmilitarymonuments.com/Sudbury-Mass.php

For March, we’ll be learning about Oliver Robinson. He was born July 30, 1766 in Stow, Middlesex County, Massachusetts to Jonathan and Eunice (Jewel/Jewell) Robinson/Robison. Early in his life the family moved to the nearby town of Sudbury, where they settled and farmed on or near land that today is home to the historic Rev. Hurlbut Parsonage. Based on later enlistment records for Oliver, we know that in his teen years he stood at about 5 foot 3 inches and sported light colored hair and blue eyes.

During the Revolution, Sudbury would see hundreds of its men sent to battle the British, including several members of the Robinson family. At the young age of 15, Oliver did similarly to fill the town quota for Sudbury. To incentivize men for their service, the town offered soldiers a combination of money and cattle - the latter would be delivered after they were discharged from service.

According to multiple sources, Oliver entered into service on April 15, 1781 for a term of three years as a private alongside his brother Zacheus. His pension file lists a different enlistment date of March 12, 1781, though this discrepancy is probably due to his memory mixing up dates as the decades passed.

Oliver was under the command of Captain Luther Bailey during his service in Colonel Sprout’s 2nd Massachusetts Regiment, and he makes no mention of any battles fought during that time. His enlistment saw him through the end of the war, where the 2nd Massachusetts was formally disbanded at West Point and Oliver was honorably discharged by Major-General Knox on December 24, 1783.

After the war, Oliver stayed close to his family for several years in the nearby town of Southborough, Massachusetts. There, he married Elizabeth “Betsey” Johnson, also of Southborough, on April 11, 1790. Notably, her ancestors had been early settlers of the Massachusetts Bay Colony with the first, William Johnson, having arrived in the Charlestown neighborhood of Boston in 1634.

Oliver Robinson’s discharge paperwork, sourced from his veteran’s pension file.

Later, in 1795, the couple and their young children would move westward to Plainfield, Massachusetts. Here they would stay for around twenty years as their family grew, with at least ten children being born to the couple in total. They would stay in Massachusetts for a few decades more until 1816 or 1817, when much of the family moved to Madison township in Ohio, which was then in Geauga County This later became a part of Lake County. Many of their children were still young, and like many in Ohio, Oliver worked as a farmer to provide for his family.

It was while living in Madison township that Oliver would file for his pension, with his name first being inscribed in the pension pay rolls on July 8, 1819. He would retain his pension until around 1820, when Congress amended the pension laws due to the high number of veterans applying for aid. This allowed the Secretary of War to remove veterans from pension rolls if they determined that said person was not in need of financial assistance. Many veterans were stricken from the rolls that year, including Oliver.

This, was sadly just the start of Oliver’s troubles. Prior to his pension filing, he cosigned on a land agreement that fell through when the borrower was unable to make payments. This resulted in a lawsuit against Oliver, as the borrower had left the state. He was ordered to pay $225, and unable to do so, had his property seized on December 17, 1821. Oliver would try to have his pension reinstated, but was only allowed a its restoration on July 24, 1827 due to a combination of property loss, his feeble health, and the death of several farm animals.

It was sometime after this that Oliver and Betsey moved to Seneca County. They most likely ended up living with one of their children, as several of them, notably Gain, Lowell, and Oliver L., had settled and began farming in Bloom township in the 1820s.

Oliver Robinson’s original grave. Rock Creek Cemetery, Seneca County, Ohio.

Oliver died on July 26, 1830, and was buried in Rock Creek Cemetery in Eden township. He has two gravestones, the original being a large stone, and the second being made to match his family’s plots. However, this isn’t the end of the story of his service. Due to an act of Congress in 1832, Betsey was able to apply for a widow’s pension. This pension was set to last only 5 years, though after many years of deliberation, Congress finally allowed for the widows of veterans to receive pensions for the rest of their lives in 1848.

Unfortunately, trouble arose for the Robinsons once again. While reviewing her pension claim, the government had a difficult time finding proof of her marriage to Oliver. This was despite the multiple testimonies of those who knew the couple, and their many children. After much back and forth, Betsey was finally accepted for a pension on July 14, 1848. She would later die on April 29, 1852, and was buried next to her husband in Rock Creek Cemetery along with several other family members.

Thank you so much to the Sudbury Historical Society over in Sudbury, Massachusetts who helped us in researching Oliver’s hometown and discovering the property which he grew up on. Without them, we wouldn’t know nearly as much about the early life of this brave veteran!

You can find their website here: https://www.sudbury01776.org/index.htm

PVT. GEORGE VALENTINE/VALLENTINE

By Jessica Hoehn, Local History and Genealogy Specialist

This February, let’s look at George Valentine/Vallentine. Most likely born on January 2, 1758 in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, George was the son of Heinrich (Henry) and Anna Maria Valentine. Heinrich was an immigrant from what is now Germany, and came to this country on September 23, 1752 aboard the Ann Galley.

George grew up in the community of Schaefferstown, Pennsylvania, one of seven or eight children in his family. He attended church at the Trinity Evangelical Lutheran in New Holland, and was according to records confirmed on April 17, 1774 at the age of 16.

Aerial view from Fort Frederick State Park, Maryland. https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/fort-frederick

When war broke out, and colonists were called to arms, George was drafted into service. He ended up re-enlisting multiple times after his first service was over, all of which are listed below:

  • Drafted in 1775 or 1776 into the Pennsylvania Line for two months into the regiment led by Colonel Clotz.

    • Commanders Include: Captain Isaac Adams

  • Enlisted at the end of his first service into the Pennsylvania Flying Camp for six months (regiment unknown)

    • Commanders Include: Captain Henry Hambright

    • Battles and Skirmishes:

      • A skirmish on Staten Island

      • Retreat from Fort Lee

      • Battle of Trenton

  • Enlisted in March of 1777 for 6 months as a Teamster in Lebanon, Pennsylvania

    • Commanders Include: Captain William Stuart

  • Drafted in the middle of fall in 1777 for two months into the regiment led by Colonel Speaker

    • Commanders Include: Captain Henry Weaver

    • Battles and Skirmishes:

      • Skirmish on Bunker Hill

  • Enlisted five or six months after his prior service for six months as a Teamster (location unknown)

    • Commanders Include: Captain Stout

  • Substituted shortly after his prior service for an unnamed man in Hagerstown, Maryland for two months

    • Commanders Unknown

    • Forts: Guarded prisoners in Fort Frederick for several weeks

  • Substituted sometime after prior service for an unnamed man in Hagerstown, Maryland for six months (regiment unknown) until Cornwallis’ surrender.

    • Commanders Include: Sargent Lewis and Captain Ott

George Caleb Bingham (1811-1879), Washington Crossing the Delaware, 1856-71. Oil on canvas.

Of George’s many enlistments seen above, one saw him become involved with a notable moment in this country’s history. In his second enlistment in the Flying Camp, George was involved in the battle of Trenton. Before the battle was to start, he recounted in his pension file how he made the historic crossing of the Delaware river.

“…we were taken over the river to Staten Island to attack the Hessians which we did at a little place called (illegible). We took the wounded and some of them the rest went aboard the shipping and escaped.”

George was one of the roughly 2,500 men to make the crossing with George Washington on Christmas night of 1776.

George Valentine’s grave. Woodlawn Cemetery, Bloomville, OH.

After the war, George moved to the area of Hagerstown, Maryland, and married Mary Grove on May 15, 1786. According to family legend, they had first met during the war while George was serving as a Teamster. While on duty, he had called upon her family’s farm house. He asked them to spare any provisions for the troops, as the army had scarce funds to exchange for supplies. Apparently smitten with the young lady of the house, he did his best to stay near her over the years, and returned to her after the war, intent on marrying her. There may be some truth to this legend, considering that after his work as a Teamster around 1778, George only reenlisted for the war in Maryland, not his native Pennsylvania.

The two remained in the Washington County area of Maryland for six or seven years before they moved over to Montgomery County. There they stayed until George was granted a land warrant in 1803. By 1806, the couple and their children had moved to Thorn Township in Fairfield County (now a part of Perry County). There George and Mary lived for around 30 years on a large farm they had cleared, and

received George’s soldier’s pension on November 1, 1832. Not long after, they sold their land and decided to move to our own Seneca County! Here, they moved in with their son John in Bloom township and lived out the rest of their days.

The couple’s children are also of note. George and Mary had two sons, John and Henry. Both sons ended up moving with their parents to Ohio before settling in Seneca County. Out of the two, John was the only one to stay in our area, with Henry eventually moving to Morrow County to live out the remainder of his life. According to records, both of George’s sons took up the call to serve the country during the War of 1812. Many of his grandsons likewise served during the Civil War, as did numerous other descendants of his and Mary in the wars thereafter.

George died on either November 27, 1838 or 1839, with his wife following in 1840. Both them and many of their descendants are buried in Woodlawn Cemetery. It seems a mistake was made with his military service marker, as he has a Civil War marker next to his grave instead of a Revolutionary one.

PVT. Aaron Dean

By Jessica Hoehn, Local History and Genealogy Specialist

It’s 2026, and that means we’re only months away from the 250th anniversary of the nation’s founding this July! To celebrate, you’re sure to see many programs and events around the community, including some of our own here at the library. As we get ready for all Seneca County has to offer for this special anniversary, let’s take a look into some of our county’s connections to the American Revolution.

Many soldiers of the Revolution left their hometowns after the war for new areas to lay down roots. Some of these soldiers eventually found their way to Ohio, often bringing their families with them to settle in the (at the time) new state. This year, we’ll take a look at those soldiers who settled in Seneca County and learn more about them.

Fort Stamford marker. Stamford, CT. https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=53433

For January, we’re focusing on Aaron Dean. Born in Stamford, Connecticut on August 16th, 1767, Aaron was the son of Ebenezer and Keziah Dean. He grew up with six or seven siblings in Stamford, one of several generations of Deans to have lived in the city.

Aaron was only a young teenager when he enlisted in the Connecticut State Troops as a private in substitute for a man only listed as “Mr. Andrus”. On December 1st of 1781, he was stationed at Fort Stamford, where he served until April 1st, 1782. Aaron then again entered the service as a substitute for a “Mr. Young” at the same fort, serving from November 1st, 1782, until April 1st, 1783.

Layout of Fort Stamford. The Stamford Historical Society Inc. https://www.stamfordhistory.org/dav_revolution.htm

In both enlistments he served in a company headed by a Captain Stoddard, though the colonel in charge changed at the fort. In his first service, the regiment was led by Colonel David Waterbury. The second time Aaron served, it was a Colonel Canfield who was in charge.

Aaron wasn’t the only member of his family to serve in the Revolution. His brothers Ebenezer, a colonel and Samuel, a private, were occasionally stationed with Aaron at Fort Stamford. Aaron, however, was the only one amongst those brothers who served the country to leave Connecticut and eventually settle in Seneca County.

According to his pension file, Aaron first moved to the borough of Kingston, Pennsylvania at the age of 19. His time in Pennsylvania is unfortunately murky, with few records to back up claims of a first

and possibly second wife. It seems that there may have been multiple Aaron Deans who lived in the area, so tracking our Aaron is difficult.

Aaron Dean’s grave. Omar Cemetery, Reed Twp., Seneca Co., OH.

We do know that later he moved to the small town of Benton, New York in 1817 where he stayed until October of 1834. It was probably somewhere in this period of his life when he married his wife Rachael, whom is the only wife of his that we can be certain of. As for his children, we do know of a son, Hallet B., who may have been born from a previous marriage. He also may have had a daughter, Sarah Elizabeth, who was born in Mendon during this time.

After Benton, Aaron moved a few counties over to Mendon, New York. It was there that he initially applied for his soldier’s pension in 1835. Aaron didn’t stay in Mendon long though, as he stated in a letter to the government in November, 1837 that he decided to move in with his son in our very own Seneca County!

Aaron stayed in Seneca County after that, living with Rachael in Reedtown alongside Hallet. On May 8, 1855 he applied for a Bounty Land Warrant, where the government further compensated his service to the country with 150 acres of land granted to him on May 28, 1856. Sadly, Aaron died before receiving his land. He passed on September 18th, 1855. He is buried with his wife in Omar Cemetery.